So that a baguazhang practitioner can move forward, a number of issues have been highlighted to me that needs clarification.
1. What does it mean when someone says they know baguazhang?
There are many forms or styles of baguazhang. When someone says they know baguazhang it is best to ask them which style. While there are stand alone baguazhang styles, most are part of a family set. For example Chen style baguazhang belongs to the Chen family kungfu house. And while you learn baguazhang, you also will learn Xingyi, Taiqi and others. Most practitioners from any school will have learned some baguazhang routines and so long as they walk in a circle they can pay lip service to the Baguazhang.
2. What is the difference between wushu and kungfu baguazhang?
Firstly, there is nothing wrong with wushu. The difference between the two are as different as learning archery for sport and learning the bow and arrow for hunting. Wushu is a sport. And for some people that is best for them.
Secondly, true kungfu is for fighting and killing. You will never see real kungfu in an arena because the outcome may be death: you learn to fight to win. There are no judges judging you on points. And this especially true for internal style practitioners, every strike you make has the potential to kill your opponent.
Thirdly, the kungfu you see in the arena is somewhere between wushu and real kungfu.
3. Should we look down upon wushu?
No. First learn the history of wushu and why it developed and visit China before making up your mind. There is a reason why wushu exists. Just like there is a reason why the hippie form of Taiqi practiced in the western parks exists even though it is not real Taiqi. And just for the record, real Taiqi is fluid, smooth and done to a quicker pace and has nothing to do with yoga. In fact, what you see in parks is not even kungfu. It is more closely related to basic qigong.
1. What does it mean when someone says they know baguazhang?
There are many forms or styles of baguazhang. When someone says they know baguazhang it is best to ask them which style. While there are stand alone baguazhang styles, most are part of a family set. For example Chen style baguazhang belongs to the Chen family kungfu house. And while you learn baguazhang, you also will learn Xingyi, Taiqi and others. Most practitioners from any school will have learned some baguazhang routines and so long as they walk in a circle they can pay lip service to the Baguazhang.
2. What is the difference between wushu and kungfu baguazhang?
Firstly, there is nothing wrong with wushu. The difference between the two are as different as learning archery for sport and learning the bow and arrow for hunting. Wushu is a sport. And for some people that is best for them.
Secondly, true kungfu is for fighting and killing. You will never see real kungfu in an arena because the outcome may be death: you learn to fight to win. There are no judges judging you on points. And this especially true for internal style practitioners, every strike you make has the potential to kill your opponent.
Thirdly, the kungfu you see in the arena is somewhere between wushu and real kungfu.
3. Should we look down upon wushu?
No. First learn the history of wushu and why it developed and visit China before making up your mind. There is a reason why wushu exists. Just like there is a reason why the hippie form of Taiqi practiced in the western parks exists even though it is not real Taiqi. And just for the record, real Taiqi is fluid, smooth and done to a quicker pace and has nothing to do with yoga. In fact, what you see in parks is not even kungfu. It is more closely related to basic qigong.
